Psychic Scams: 7 Schemes, Red Flags & How to Spot a Fake Psychic (2026)

Psychic scams follow a predictable script: a curse, a costly fix, secrecy and endless new problems. The 7 schemes AARP, USPIS and the BBB keep seeing, real reported losses, red flags of a fake psychic and where to report.

Home » Blog » Psychic Scams: 7 Schemes, Red Flags & How to Spot a Fake Psychic (2026)

Most people who book a psychic reading want the same thing: a little clarity, comfort or perspective for a set price. Psychic scams turn that small, defined purchase into an open-ended money drain. The pattern is remarkably consistent across police reports, AARP case files and Better Business Bureau complaints: a “curse” is discovered, a costly ritual is the only cure, and the work is never quite finished. This guide breaks down the scams that consumer watchdogs actually document, the warning signs that separate a fraud from an ordinary reader, and exactly what to do and where to report if it has already happened to you or someone you love.

Updated November 22, 2026. Facts and case figures below come from AARP, the U.S. Postal Inspection Service (USPIS), the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and news reports, linked in the text. Individual cases are reported losses, not independent audits. We have not tested or investigated any specific reader for this article. If you have lost money, contact your bank first, then the agencies listed in the reporting section.

What counts as a psychic scam (and what doesn’t)

There is no scientific evidence that psychic perception works, so skeptics would argue every paid reading is a bad deal. That is a separate debate. For consumer protection purposes, the useful line is simpler: an ordinary reading is a defined service at a stated price; a scam uses fear, secrecy or false promises to extract money beyond that.

AARP describes the classic fraud plainly: a self-described psychic may promise to remove a curse, restore your health, bring riches or return a lost love, all for a fee (AARP). The U.S. Postal Inspection Service calls the operators “spiritual scammers with no psychic gifts” and describes the experience for victims as an “emotional roller-coaster ride” (USPIS).

Ordinary paid readingPsychic scam
Price agreed before the session (per minute or flat fee)Small or free first reading, then large “ritual” or “cleansing” fees
Reader shares impressions; you decide what to doReader “discovers” a curse, dark aura or danger that only they can fix
Session ends; you can leave and never returnThe work is never finished; new problems keep appearing
Payment by card through a platform with refund rulesCash, gift cards, Zelle, Cash App or wire; sometimes cash “to be returned”
No pressure to keep it secretTold not to tell family, friends or your bank

7 psychic scams watchdogs keep seeing

1. The curse-removal scam

The most common pattern. During a cheap reading, the “psychic” announces that you, your family or your money carries a curse, a hex or negative energy. USPIS lists promises to “remove a bad luck curse” as a core feature of the fraud, and Bitdefender’s summary of BBB reports notes that the curse can only be lifted for a hefty sum (Bitdefender). The curse explains every bad thing in your life, which is exactly what makes it persuasive.

2. The “cursed money” cleansing scam

The scammer claims your money itself is contaminated and must be handed over to be cleansed, blessed or “worked on” before it is returned. In one case reported by AARP, a New Jersey man was told “You have a curse,” then asked to bring $9,000 in a pillowcase for a ritual; the money was never returned (AARP). A BBB Scam Tracker report quoted by Bitdefender describes a “money cleansing ritual” charged per session. Any request to hand over money that will be “given back later” should end the relationship immediately.

3. The evil-spirits cleansing upsell

A variation sold as spiritual protection: evil spirits, entities or a “dark aura” are attached to you and must be cleared. A BBB warning reported in 2021 described a client who paid $3,500 to a self-described psychic to fight “evil spirits,” was pressured to pay an extra cleansing fee and was then ignored after asking for a refund (The State via Yahoo News).

4. Social media “influencer psychics” who take payment and vanish

According to the BBB, this version is particularly common on social media. The reader advertises on TikTok, Instagram or Facebook, takes payment up front through peer-to-peer apps like Zelle or Cash App, misses sessions and becomes unreachable when the client asks for a refund. Peer-to-peer payments are hard to reverse, which is why scammers prefer them. In 2022, CTV News reported that a 21-year-old Ontario woman lost $11,000 to a Texas psychic she met on TikTok after her stepfather died (CTV News).

5. Love and “get your ex back” spells

Romance is the emotional lever in many of the largest losses. USPIS notes that fraudsters promise to help victims find their soulmate; AARP’s case files include people who paid tens of thousands of dollars to reconnect with a partner or win back an ex. A cheaper modern twist reported to the BBB: a “psychic artist” who charges to draw your future soulmate and delivers what appear to be AI-generated pictures. If you are going through a breakup, read our guide to love readings and keep any spending capped in advance.

6. Mass-mail psychic letters

Personalized-looking letters announce that a famous seer has seen a fortune or danger in your future, and ask for a payment to receive the full prediction or a lucky talisman. AARP reports that in 2016 the federal government shut down a mail-based ring whose losses were estimated at $180 million across roughly 1 million Americans, and the operators were barred from mailing psychic materials. These letters target older adults and keep coming once a name is on a “sucker list,” so returned payments generate more mail.

7. “Free reading” hooks and data harvesting

Free mini-readings are a legitimate marketing tool for many platforms, but they are also the most common entry point for scams. Bitdefender warns readers to be very cautious about free readings and describes requests for full names, dates of birth, ID documents and card details that go well beyond what any reading needs. Phone hotlines have a history here too: AARP recalls that the companies behind the “Miss Cleo” ads were charged with deceptively marketing paid readings as free services.

Pattern to remember: cheap or free entry → a frightening discovery → a costly fix → secrecy → “the work isn’t finished.” Every documented scam above follows some version of these five steps.

Real cases and reported losses

The figures below are individual reported cases and estimates cited by AARP, CTV News, the BBB and Australia’s ACCC (via Bitdefender). They show scale, not typical outcomes, and some victims never recovered anything because police declined to pursue the case.

Reported losses in individual psychic scam cases Horizontal bar chart on a logarithmic-style ranking: $3.5 million Martha’s Vineyard case; $24,000 Canada; $20,000 Seattle; $11,000 Ontario TikTok case; $9,000 New Jersey; $3,500 BBB evil spirits case. Reported losses in individual psychic-scam cases (USD) Bar length is not to scale for the $3.5M case (shown truncated). Sources: AARP, CTV News, BBB. Martha’s Vineyard, MA$3.5M Canada, age 54$24,000 Seattle, age 72$20,000 Ontario (TikTok), age 21$11,000 New Jersey (pillowcase)$9,000 BBB “evil spirits” case$3,500
Amounts as reported by AARP (psychic scams during COVID-19), CTV News (Aug 2022) and The State/BBB (June 2021). Currency for the Canadian cases as reported.
Case (as reported)HookReported lossSource
Woman with dementia, Martha’s Vineyard; psychic prosecuted in 2018Ongoing “spiritual” services$3.5 millionAARP
Woman, 54, CanadaReconnecting with a loved one$24,000AARP
Woman, 72, SeattleInformation about a new relationship$20,000AARP
Woman, 21, OntarioTikTok psychic after a death in the family$11,000CTV News
Man in his 50s, New Jersey“Cursed” money in a pillowcase$9,000AARP
Client of a social media psychicFighting “evil spirits,” then a cleansing fee$3,500BBB via The State
Mail-based psychic ring shut down in 2016Personalized prediction letters~$180 million (est.), ~1 million peopleAARP
Australia, 2022 (207 reports)Psychic and clairvoyant scamsOver $500,000 totalACCC Scamwatch via Bitdefender

Two details stand out. First, many victims were grieving, recently separated or out of work: the scam finds people at a vulnerable moment. Second, several reported that police would not take the case, often treating it as a civil dispute because the victim “agreed” to pay. That is why documentation and fast reporting matter.

The script: how a scam escalates step by step

Fraudulent readers rarely ask for thousands on day one. Watchdog descriptions and victim accounts follow a similar arc:

  1. Low-cost entry. A free or cheap reading, a storefront sign, a social media ad or a letter.
  2. Cold reading. Broad statements (“you’ve been carrying a weight”, “someone close doesn’t appreciate you”) that feel personal. Bitdefender and other sources describe this technique as the foundation of the pitch.
  3. The discovery. A curse, dark energy or danger is “seen,” usually explaining a real problem: illness, a breakup, money trouble.
  4. The fix. Candles, prayers, crystals, “cleansing” of money or jewelry, each with a price.
  5. Secrecy. You are told the work fails if you tell anyone. AARP specifically advises not to follow instructions to keep it secret.
  6. Escalation. New negativity appears after each ritual. USPIS describes the cycle as continuing to require more and more money.
  7. Fear or disappearance. If you hesitate, threats (“the curse will fall on your children”); if you ask for a refund, silence.

How to spot a fake psychic: red flags vs. normal practice

A reader can be sincere and still not be right about anything; that is a question of belief. These red flags, drawn from AARP, USPIS and BBB guidance, are about something different: behavior that signals fraud.

Red flagWhy it matters
Guaranteed results (a lover returns, health restored, a windfall)AARP lists guaranteed outcomes as a top warning sign. No honest reader can guarantee another person’s choices.
A curse, hex or “dark aura” that only they can removeThe core of the most common scam. Fear is the sales tool.
New problems keep appearing after each paymentSignals an open-ended extraction scheme, not a service.
Requests for cash, gift cards, crypto, wire or peer-to-peer paymentsThese are hard or impossible to reverse.
Asking you to hand over money, gold or jewelry “to be cleansed”The property is rarely returned.
Demands for secrecy from family or your bankIsolation removes the people most likely to stop the scam.
Requests for ID, Social Security number or card details beyond paymentNo reading requires them; this is data harvesting.
Threats if you stop payingAARP flags threats as a key sign; consider contacting police or the FBI.
No verifiable reviews, or only comments the reader controlsThe BBB suggests checking comments on social accounts carefully.

Normal practice looks boring by comparison: a posted per-minute or flat price, payment by card through a platform, a session that ends when the time is up, and no follow-up sales pitch. We cover how to evaluate individual readers in more depth in how to vet a psychic reader and 10 tips to avoid scams.

How to get a reading without getting scammed

If you still want a reading, treat it like any other entertainment or personal-services purchase. AARP’s Amy Nofziger put it simply in an AARP interview: use a psychic or palm reader as entertainment.

  • Set a budget before you start and write it down. Decide in advance that no “ritual,” “cleansing” or “protection work” will be purchased, ever.
  • Know the going rate. Our breakdown of how much a psychic reading costs shows typical per-minute pricing on major platforms; anything far above that deserves a hard look.
  • Pay by credit card through a platform with a published refund or satisfaction policy, not by cash, gift card or Zelle to an individual. Platforms with timed chat or phone sessions cap your spending automatically. See phone readings and free psychic chat offers.
  • Get prices in writing. AARP advises getting appointment details and future costs in writing; USPIS suggests asking about hidden costs up front.
  • Talk to someone you trust before paying for anything beyond the reading itself. USPIS recommends exactly this.
  • Never share your Social Security number, ID documents, online banking logins or card details outside a secure checkout.
  • Bring focused questions so the session doesn’t drift into fear-based territory. Our list of what to ask a psychic can help.

Already paid? What to do and where to report

Many victims feel embarrassed, which is exactly what scammers count on. Reporting quickly increases the chance of stopping payments and helps investigators connect cases.

  1. Stop all payments and do not respond to new demands or threats.
  2. Call your bank or card issuer immediately to dispute charges or attempt to recall transfers. Card payments are generally easier to dispute than cash or peer-to-peer apps.
  3. Save everything: messages, social media profiles, receipts, payment confirmations, phone numbers, addresses.
  4. Report it to the agencies below.
WhereWhen to use itHow
Federal Trade CommissionPaid service not delivered, deceptive offersReportFraud.ftc.gov
FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3)Online or app-based fraud; AARP names IC3 as the place for psychic-fraud complaintsic3.gov
Local FBI field office or policeThreats, pressure, large lossesCall or visit; AARP recommends the FBI if you feel threatened
U.S. Postal Inspection ServicePsychic letters or payments sent by mailuspis.gov/report or 1-877-876-2455
BBB Scam TrackerWarn others and log the businessbbb.org/scamtracker
AARP Fraud Watch Network HelplineFree guidance for anyone, any age877-908-3360
Beware “recovery” offers. Victims of one scam are often contacted by someone promising to get the money back, or to lift the curse properly, for a fee. Treat any unsolicited recovery offer as a second scam.

Protecting a parent or friend

Older adults, people who are grieving and people with cognitive decline are targeted most often; AARP’s largest case involved a woman with dementia. If you are worried about someone:

  • Ask open, non-judgmental questions (“Has anyone offered to help with that?”) rather than mocking their beliefs. Shame pushes people toward secrecy, which helps the scammer.
  • Watch for unusual cash withdrawals, gift card purchases, new “spiritual advisors,” or sudden reluctance to discuss money.
  • Help them set up account alerts or a trusted contact with their bank.
  • Remove their name from mass-mail lists where possible and help sort incoming mail if letters keep arriving.
  • Explain that a genuine reader never needs to hold their money and that secrecy requests are a scam sign, not a spiritual rule.

Belief in psychics is common: AARP cites Pew research finding that about four in ten U.S. adults believe in psychics. Respecting someone’s beliefs and protecting their money are not in conflict.

FAQ

Are all psychics scams?

There is no scientific evidence that psychic abilities exist, so many skeptics consider any paid reading money poorly spent. Consumer agencies draw a narrower line: a reading sold at a clear price is a service; a scam uses curses, fear, false guarantees and secrecy to extract money beyond that. Most fraud warnings target the second group.

What is the most common psychic scam?

Curse removal. The reader claims you or your money is cursed and that only expensive rituals or “cleansings” can fix it. AARP, USPIS and BBB reports all describe this pattern, often with escalating fees.

How do I spot a fake psychic?

Watch for guaranteed outcomes, a curse only they can lift, requests to hand over money or jewelry to be cleansed, cash or gift card payments, demands for secrecy and new problems appearing after every payment. Any one of these is reason to stop.

Can I get my money back from a psychic scammer?

Sometimes. Contact your bank or card issuer immediately: card payments can often be disputed, while cash, gift cards and peer-to-peer transfers are much harder to recover. Then report to the FTC, IC3 and local police, and keep every record.

Is it illegal for a psychic to charge for a reading?

Charging for a reading is generally legal in the U.S., though some local laws regulate fortune-telling businesses. Fraud, theft by deception and extortion are illegal everywhere, and psychics have been prosecuted for them, including the 2018 Martha’s Vineyard case reported by AARP.

Are free psychic readings a scam?

Not automatically. Many platforms offer a few free minutes as a promotion. The risk is when a free reading leads to an alarming “discovery” and a paid fix. Use free offers on platforms with clear pricing, and never pay for curse removal.

Where do I report a psychic scam?

The FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, the FBI’s IC3 at ic3.gov for online fraud, local police or the FBI for threats, USPIS for mail-based scams, and BBB Scam Tracker to warn others. The AARP Fraud Watch Network Helpline (877-908-3360) offers free guidance.

What should I do if a psychic says I’m cursed?

End the conversation and do not pay anything. A claimed curse that requires payment to remove is the signature of the most common psychic scam. If you feel frightened or threatened, talk to someone you trust and consider contacting the police.

Sources: AARP: Psychic Scams; AARP: Psychic Scams Rise During COVID-19; USPIS: Psychic Scam; Bitdefender: Psychic and fortune-telling scams; CTV News (2022); The State via Yahoo News (2021). Related: how to assess psychic claims and credentials.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *